diff --git a/jarvis/utils/cogs.py b/jarvis/utils/cogs.py
index f176a10..ff757e5 100644
--- a/jarvis/utils/cogs.py
+++ b/jarvis/utils/cogs.py
@@ -7,6 +7,7 @@ from jarvis_core.db.models import Action, Ban, Kick, Modlog, Mute, Setting, Warn
 from naff import Client, Extension, InteractionContext
 from naff.models.discord.components import ActionRow, Button, ButtonStyles
 from naff.models.discord.embed import EmbedField
+from naff.models.discord.user import Member
 
 from jarvis.utils import build_embed
 
@@ -113,9 +114,10 @@ class ModcaseCog(Extension):
                     description=f"Would you like to open a moderation case for {user.mention}?",
                     fields=[],
                 )
-                embed.set_author(
-                    name=user.username + "#" + user.discriminator, icon_url=user.display_avatar.url
-                )
+                avatar_url = user.avatar.url
+                if isinstance(user, Member):
+                    avatar_url = user.display_avatar.url
+                embed.set_author(name=user.username + "#" + user.discriminator, icon_url=avatar_url)
                 components = [
                     ActionRow(
                         Button(style=ButtonStyles.RED, emoji="✖️", custom_id="modcase|no"),